Study Removed | Pooled Effect | 95% CI | I2 (%) | Heterogeneity Change |
---|---|---|---|---|
Shuangling Xiu 2021 [13] | − 1.20 | [− 1.47, − 0.94] | 97.30 | Minimal |
Fuyuko Takahashi 2021 [14] | − 1.20 | [− 1.46, − 0.94] | 97.34 | Minimal |
Ken Sugimoto 2021 [16] | − 1.19 | [− 1.45, − 0.94] | 97.26 | Slight decrease |
Vatana V. Sundar 2021 [17] | − 1.28 | [− 1.53, − 1.02] | 97.36 | Slight increase |
Xiaofan Zhang 2021 [18] | − 1.26 | [− 1.52, − 1.00] | 97.34 | Minimal |
Hiroyasu Mori 2021 [20] | − 1.21 | [− 1.48, − 0.95] | 97.33 | Minimal |
Kentaro Mikura 2022 [21] | − 1.23 | [− 1.50, − 0.96] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
Yoshitaka Hashimoto 2022 [22] | − 1.22 | [− 1.49, − 0.95] | 97.41 | Slight increase |
Yoshihisa Hiromine 2022 [23] | − 1.20 | [− 1.46, − 0.94] | 97.24 | Slight decrease |
Kewei Wang 2022 [24] | − 1.24 | [− 1.51, − 0.97] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
Sayani Das 2023 [25] | − 1.23 | [− 1.50, − 0.96] | 97.41 | Slight increase |
Ming-Jun Chen 2023 [26] | − 1.24 | [− 1.51, − 0.97] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
G.-C. Ma 2023 [27] | − 1.22 | [− 1.49, − 0.95] | 97.40 | Minimal |
Fuyuko Takahashi 2023 [28] | − 1.22 | [− 1.49, − 0.96] | 97.41 | Slight increase |
Mijin Kim 2023 [29] | − 1.25 | [− 1.51, − 0.98] | 97.37 | Minimal |
Lanyu Lu 2023 [30] | − 1.25 | [− 1.52, − 0.98] | 97.39 | Minimal |
Lei Fu 2023 [31] | − 1.26 | [− 1.53, − 1.00] | 97.28 | Minimal |
Yu-Ting Hsu 2023 [33] | − 1.25 | [− 1.52, − 0.98] | 97.40 | Minimal |
Surapaneni L.S. 2023 [34] | − 1.23 | [− 1.50, − 0.96] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
Hsin-Yen Yen 2023 [35] | − 1.20 | [− 1.46, − 0.94] | 97.29 | Minimal |
Yinghe Lin 2023 [36] | − 1.23 | [− 1.50, − 0.96] | 97.41 | Slight increase |
Wen Wei 2023 [37] | − 1.23 | [− 1.50, − 0.97] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
Lina Sun 2023 [38] | − 1.20 | [− 1.46, − 0.94] | 97.31 | Minimal |
Ke Xu 2024 [39] | − 1.22 | [− 1.49, − 0.96] | 97.39 | Minimal |
Chun-hui Ji 2024 [40] | − 1.23 | [− 1.50, − 0.96] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
Yogesh M 2024 [41] | − 1.26 | [− 1.52, − 1.00] | 97.24 | Slight decrease |
Mingrui Zou 2024 [42] | − 1.20 | [− 1.47, − 0.94] | 97.26 | Slight decrease |
Sohye Kim 2024 [43] | − 1.25 | [− 1.52, − 0.99] | 97.10 | Moderate decrease |
Yang Sun 2024 [44] | − 1.25 | [− 1.52, − 0.99] | 97.36 | Minimal |
Li Quan 2024 [45] | − 1.23 | [− 1.50, − 0.96] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
Yogesh M (2nd) 2024 [41] | − 1.28 | [− 1.53, − 1.02] | 97.12 | Moderate decrease |
Satoshi Ida 2024 [47] | − 1.22 | [− 1.49, − 0.95] | 97.39 | Minimal |
Motoya Sato 2024 [48] | − 1.26 | [− 1.52, − 1.00] | 97.36 | Minimal |
Bingmei Hou 2024 [49] | − 1.22 | [− 1.48, − 0.95] | 97.35 | Minimal |
Rimesh Pal 2024 [50] | − 1.24 | [− 1.51, − 0.97] | 97.42 | Slight increase |
Shiyue Zou 2024 [51] | − 1.26 | [− 1.52, − 0.99] | 97.34 | Minimal |